|
Business-Managed Democracy‘Business-managed democracies are those in which the political and cultural
Toll on Children
USA Reference: Jonathan Kozol, The Shame of the Nation: The Restoration of Apartheid Schooling in America, New York, Crown Publishers, 2005, pp. 113-5; Valerie Strauss, ‘The Rise of the Testing Culture’, Washington Post, 10 October, 2006, p. A09.
The high stakes attached to standardised testing has resulted in a push for students to begin academic studies at an earlier age as schools compete to outdo each other in the tests in the US. There are standardised tests in kindergarten in some states. In Alabama, kindergarten children are subjected to tests three times in a year. Children are even tested in pre-school programs for literacy and math, when they are only four years old. Reference: Sally Kalson, ‘Back to School: From Reading to Algebra, Everything in School Is Starting Earlier’, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 27 August, 2006
Reference: Sally Kalson, ‘Back to School: From Reading to Algebra, Everything in School Is Starting Earlier’, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 27 August, 2006
This trend has increased the number of students dropping out of school as they are unable to cope with the accelerated pace of learning. Reference: George Wood, ‘A View from the Field: NCLB's Effects on Classrooms and Schools’, in Deborah Meier and George Wood (eds) Many Children Left Behind: How the No Child Left Behind Act Is Damaging Our Children and Our Schools, Boston, Mass., Beacon Press, 2004, p. 37; Valerie Strauss, ‘The Rise of the Testing Culture’, Washington Post, 10 October, 2006, p. A09.
Some states are requiring schools to retain elementary students if they do not pass a standardised reading test, despite evidence that children learn to read at different rates and start at different levels when they begin school. Consequently children who develop later get an inferiority complex early in life. Pre-school and kindergarten children are especially likely to be traumatised by tests and labelled as poor performers before they even begin school. Reference: Debra Nussbaum, ‘Before Children Ask, 'What's Recess?'’, New York Times, 10 December, 2006; Penelope H. Bevan, ‘Let Children Be Children’, San Francisco Chronicle, 2007, p. E-2.
The increased intensity of academic schooling is also making school an unpleasant place for children, particularly as recesses are reduced or cut altogether so they get no opportunity to stretch or play or develop social skills. “The present emphasis on testing and test scores is sucking the soul out of the primary school experience for both teachers and children.” Reference: Christine French Clark, ‘The State of the Kid: 2009 Survey Results’, Highlights for Children, Inc, Columbus, OH, 2009, p. 4. (pdf)
The State of the Kid 2009 Report found that the number one problem for US children was school work, including their performance in school tests. Reference: Peter Whoriskey, ‘Political Backlash Builds over High Stakes Testing’, Washington Post, 23 October, 2006, p. A03.
Record numbers of children are depressed. Children get so stressed over the tests that some are vomiting on the morning of their tests. Parental opposition to high-stakes testing is growing. Australia Reference: William McKeith, ‘Even for Seven-Year-Olds, Exams Are Taking the Fun out of Being a Kid’, Sydney Morning Herald, 2003, p. 15.
William McKeith, principal of a Sydney school, notes that the culture of testing in NSW is causing children to lose the time they need to play, relax and “construct their own activities… Some of us can remember after school hours, fun times, filled with bicycle riding, dress-ups and cricket in the backyard with friends…. Many of our children are now either too tired or too busy for such innocent activities. It isn’t surprising that increasingly we are hearing doctors and psychologists report concerns with childhood stress, anxiety, poor sleep and obesity”. UK Reference: ‘Tests 'Stopping Children Playing'’, BBC News, 5 April, 2007
In the UK, according to the Association of Teachers and Lecturers, children as young as five are not able to play because they are under so much pressure from national tests. They become bored with the constant assessment and dislike school from the their first year. Reference: Richard Garner, ‘Testing Blamed for Rise in Primary School Truancy’, The Independent, 22 September, 2006; Katherine Sellgren, ‘Tests 'Reduce Pupils to Widgets'’, BBC News, 4 May, 2007.
Rising truancy rates and increasing numbers of children leaving school early have been blamed on high stakes testing which, according to the National Association of Head Teachers, is causing children to feel stressed and disenfranchised; reducing children “to widgets on a production line”; and reducing schools to “exam factories”. Reference: Quoted in William McKeith, ‘Even for Seven-Year-Olds, Exams Are Taking the Fun out of Being a Kid’, Sydney Morning Herald, 2003, p. 15.
The Times Education Supplement found that “more than a third of seven-year olds suffer stress over national tests and one in 10 loses sleep because they are so worried about them…. By the age of 11, two thirds of children show symptoms of stress as they revise for national tests.” See also: Toll on Teachers | Leaving Children Behind | Cheating
© 2009 Sharon Beder
|