site logo

Business-Managed Democracy

“Business-managed democracies are those in which the political and cultural arrangements are managed in the interests of business”

Sharon Beder

Business-Managed Culture

Twitter

Twitter logoTwitter is a social networking forum where users’ messages and responses are limited to 140 characters, called ‘tweets’. Tweets show how many people have clicked “like” and how many people have “retweeted” them. Only registered users can post messages but anyone can read them. Messages can be posted online, or via mobile phone SMS messages. Launched in 2006, ten years later it claimed about 320 million active registered users each month, 82% of them via mobile devices, 79% of them outside the US using 40 languages.

reference

Twitter's US advertising revenue in 2016 was almost $1.4billion, $857million internationally.

reference

At first it seemed that Twitter and other social media forums would facilitate democracy by enabling widespread and diverse conversations on political and social issues, encouraging political engagement and the ability to coordinate protest activity. However it soon became apparent that those conversations could be hijacked and the medium could just as easily be used to manipulate social opinion and spread political misinformation.

back to top

Twitter Bots

reference

twitter botAlthough users must register, they can remain anonymous on the forum, and they can use false identities to register. This opens the forum up to the use of Twitter bots, “accounts that look real, but that are controlled by a puppet master.”

reference

Benevenuto and his colleagues created 120 bot accounts, making sure each one had a convincing profile complete with picture and attributes such as gender. After a month, they found that almost 70% of the bots were left untouched by Twitter’s bot detection mechanisms. What’s more, the bots were pre-programmed to interact with other users and quickly attracted a healthy band of followers, 4,999 in total.

reference

Most Twitter users do not or cannot differentiate between bots and humans. It has been estimated that “between 9 and 15% of active Twitter accounts are bots”.

reference

Twitter bots are cheap to buy and the software to create them is readily available and easy to use. “Descriptions of how to build Twitter bots are widely available on the web, and they can even be purchased en masse from companies that specialise in developing them”. In this way a few people, or a single person, can appear to be a very large group of people; “it lets them use Twitter as a megaphone”. And tweets can garner many likes and retweets and therefore appear to be popular and in this way to “manufacture consensus” as well as spread propaganda.

reference

Readily available bots can:

reference

Bots graphicSocial bots, because they are automated, can respond to twitter streams far more rapidly than humans and send out a greater mass of messages, yet still appear to be human to readers of Twitter. These are called Twitter bombs or tweet bombs.

reference

Bots can be programmed “to retweet certain topics (like chocolate or Ebola), favorite a tweet or follow anyone who follows them”. Since they do not verify what they are retweeting, false information and accusations can be widely circulated.

reference

Twitter is used by share traders to indicate when something might be happening that will affect the share market, causing them to buy or sell shares. However this information is not checked for veracity by the automatic share traders.  For example, a false rumour of a terrorist attack on President Obama in 2010 caused a flash crash on the US stock market when the Dow Jones lost 9% in a few minutes. In another example a company used a bot campaign to talk up its value, resulting in its share market value increasing 200 times.

back to top
See also: Facebook | Google

See also: Twitter News
See also: Bots